Tuesday, April 21, 2009



Creative people need feedback. That concept cannot be argued at all. We need criticism. Constructive criticism. But sometimes, there is born a creative like myself who needs something else.
I've always been the sort of person who needed approval in life. Whether it was a job well done or a drawing painted, i needed that pat on the back. Unfortunately, despite glowing praises and accolades of attention one harsh word from any one remotely significant person had the ability to destroy me. I used to dwell on the negative comments more than on the positive ones. It was a flaw. It is a flaw. Thankfully, it is one of those things people normally cannot tell about me. I come forth as super confident, super positive super human to most people. Throughout college my work was always bold and my presentations extremely well delivered. I actually admit that myself. Arrogant as it may sound, it is the truth that my work was great. Not flawless, but great. I got rave reviews when my i presented my final college thesis. It was an ambitious project for an undergrad thesis but i did it. I pulled it off. One juror, though, remained unimpressed. He gave me an 80% as opposed to my other two jurors who gave me 92% each. I knew it was just bad luck, i knew not everyone can love a specific piece of work... but it bothered the hell out of me. My mother calls it a "Virgo" trait.
In six days i launch that undergrad thesis as a proper re-vamped coffee-table book. Again, i am putting myself out there to be judged, criticized, appreciated and...judged again by a bigger, meaner crowd. The entire creative industry of Pakistan. Life would be so much simpler if people were nicer. If their harsh comments were spoken in softer tones, if the world wasn't so eager to put other people down so that they can seem cooler. Where as one part of me is ridiculously excited that this book is about to be launched another side of me is bracing myself for the hideous and ugly comments i may have to hear. I never built that wall around me. I tried very hard to but i couldn't. I can pretend very well, that mean things don't affect me. But they do. A lot. More than they should. But where lies one weakness, lies one strength to pull one through it. And my strength is that i am great at moving on. No matter how profusely i hurt over broken hearts and broken promises, over lies and betrayal...eventually i move on and stop hurting. After sometime, i can actually smile at the offender and truly feel good about smiling at them.
Anyway,
this post has turned into more of a heart pour rather than my usual morally constructive posts. There is one moral here though; trying to please everyone may not always be a bad thing...not building a wall around you can be good too...at least you know you tried and at least you know you lived.

Will post after the launch now.
Wish me luck ppl! :)

18 comments:

Khizzy said...

booboo...i will smother you if i even see the slightest hunch in your shoulders later.
stop thinking about it and lets get excited about sunday.
eeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee!!!
i have my outfit planned and ive been told yours is done too.lol. please dwell on the mindless fun details for now.
plenty of time to worry about moronic reviews... because that is exactly what i will convince you they are.lol.
im so proud of you...i'll be the crazy person stopping people and teling them, "im kAys best friend..yup me...yes i am!! yup yup1"

lol. ok so i wont. i will be at my best cool, composed, and 'sophisticated behavior.

the free spirit said...

Good luck...Im sure the book will do great... :)

Faraz said...

Good luck! :)

If you can, let me know how I can buy your book.

Ali said...

Where will us poor Punjab dwelling peeps be able to buy?

Interestingly, word verification is: hatre.

Mix the letter around to see what i believe you to have in abundance :)

Valkyrie said...

Ok I have something to share but first just out of sheer curiosity I am trying to relate your last image with its caption and unable to reach a conclusion:S

kAy said...

thanks all for the support :)

ali- :) thank you. i actually love anagrams so this was simple and sweet of you :)

Valkyrie- i am not surprised you mentioned the imagery. i was waiting for someone to question its relevance. it was more of a personal moment. The girl in the picture was not pleased with me at the point this picture was taken. I kept trying to put her in a better mood. the kiss was supposed to signify me not quitting trying...despite her clear lack of interest as seen in the first pic.

as aneela says, i tend to suffer from the "disease to please" :)

karachi khatmal said...

i recently found your blog, and i'm really impressed by your work - great job!

what is the name of your book btw?

as for the post itself, it's far better as a creative person to have a need to please, because then you are attuned to criticisms that your adoring loved ones can't never objectively identify. but it's vital to have one's ego about, because otherwise you can never defend your own creations and that is criminal. i get the feeling you are on the right path - best of luck :)

Valkyrie said...

Aneela’s verdict clearly reflects everything you mentioned in your post. “Disease to please” can virtually lead to a zero tolerance of any criticism coming through close affiliations. Super positivity and confidence may also strengthen your faith in all those around you and one harsh comment can completely destroy your morale to an unimaginable level.
I have always failed to understand ‘constructive criticism’ how does one define it? How does one draw line between constructive and destructive criticism? Everyone has a different interpretation and tolerance level to accept or react to it
You are uniquely creative and must exercise a certain degree of arrogance to maintain exclusivity. Great artists did:)
Approval is good, pat is always needed, reliance, however is a flaw and potentially fatal. Your book is about to hit the market so you must mentally prepare yourself to accept all the accolades, praises, criticism and damaging remarks. It wont be your last effort:)
On a light note I am particularly impressed with your certain efforts to pacify your friend, wondering if your boys ever displayed any narazgi hoping for an idea solution..lol

Valkyrie said...

I just noticed you hvnt put a title

OnLY OnE..! said...

GOOD LUCK for the book, am more than sure you will do well!
Is there a way to buy it if you don't live in Pakistan...i.e...somewhere like Canada?!?!

Saady said...

Good luck kAy. I am very happy for you.

I am sure that you already know that sometimes when people offer positive criticisms, the sole purpose for them is to help you get better. I guess you already know that so i'll forgo my bhaashan ! haha

Good luck and I am sure you'll be a super hit !

Its been a pleasure following your blog even though i haven't always agreed with you. I am sure the book will turn out great too !

excited for you !

mittsophy said...

Apart from your close-knit family and friends' circle, I'd be the last one standing to get hold of your book. Love the contents already. Haven't ever met up with you but you DO send out really outlandish vibes.

Your photo blog rocks!
And so should the book!

And no, I don't have a knack for glossing over parts that deserve otherwise. Would surely send you feedbacks!

God Speed then,

Love and Luck, Maryam-

kAy said...

Karachi Khatmal:
first off thats a very interesting pseudonym. khatmal. weirdly nice.. even if they are lil bugs that eat away at things :)
thank you for your encouraging words.
rest assured i am quite the defender when it comes to my work. i may even border on being too defensive. as my photography professor from college puts it "kAy is too aggressive when it comes to getting what she wants- i cant decide if i should congratulate her for it or smack her!" lol

Valkyrie: i can explain "constructive criticism". its rather simple. some ppl criticize you by just saying "it was terrible" full stop. constructive criticism would tell you WHY they thought it was terrible, what went wrong and what could have been done in its place to improve it. if you fail to give the last two responses and and if i canNOT have a discussion with that person to know whether or not he has an actual point or if its just artistic differences he and i have, that persons opinion is useless to me.
i cannot really bring myself to respect an opinion that no thought has gone into and what could simply be spoken because that somebody had a bad day at work or an equally frivolous reason!

as for "my boys". I used to have "boys". there are sadly none left! :P

only one: inshallah it will be available online. probably amazon if not the publishing website.
will keep you posted :)
thanks for dropping by.

Saady: the beauty of conversation are the disagreements. how terribly boring the world would be if we all looked at things the same way !
that is a very strong theme in my book as well :)
thanks for always commenting. :)

mittsophy: :) thank you for all you messages (both here and the pvt ones) will keep you updates as well about where you can get a copy!
and certainly do send me honest feedback.
:)

nick said...

The person who is ANYBODY and who does anything is surely going to be criticized, vilified, and misunderstood. This is part of the penalty for greatness.(Elbert Hubbard)
so you gonna b criticized thats for sure. you know na you can NOT please every single person on earth. but i m sure you gonna b appreciated more than criticized.
best of luck.

Aneela Z said...

chalo sweetie when you are done celebrating please take up this tag

http://golkamra.blogspot.com/2009/04/kissa-number-ka.html

OnLY OnE..! said...

I read your blog religiously, I think I have for the last 4-5 years....so am always dropping by!
Do lemme know if you find out I can somehow get it...thanks :)

Ali said...

atleast tell us the name
:( :(

Vaqas said...

"Never ask people. Not about your work."
Howard Roark (The Fountainhead)